Template talk:MapsYear

Automatic Categorisation under "Category:Maps showing the DECADEs"

Hi, the YEAR-maps-categories (e.g. Category:2010 maps) containing:

maps created in this year (e.g. Category:Maps created in 2010‎) and
maps showing the year (e.g. Category:Maps showing 2010, Category:Maps showing 2011).

So an automatic categorisation under "Category:Maps showing the DECADEs" (e.g: Category:Maps showing the 2010s) becomes difficult.

--- --- --- --- ---

The sitation now explained by one example (Category:2010 maps), invers Category Tree:

Category:2010 maps (containing maps showing the year and maps created in this year) is autom. classified under:
... * Category:Maps showing the 2010s (only!! showing the year)
... ... – Category:Maps showing 21st-century history
... ... – Category:2010s
... * Category:Maps by year

Category:2010s maps (showing and created)
... * Category:Maps made in the 21st century (only!! created/made in this year)

--- --- --- --- ---

Sitation proposed explained by one example, invers Category Tree:

Category:Maps showing 2010 (showing)
... * Category:Maps showing the 2010s (showing)
... ... – Category:Maps showing 21st-century history (showing)
... * Category:2010 maps (showing and created)
... ... – Category:2010s maps (showing and created)
... ... – Category:Maps by year (showing and created)

Category:Maps created in 2010 (created)
... * Category:Maps created in the 2010s (created)
... ... – Category:Maps made in the 21st century (created/made)
... * Category:2010 works (created)
... * Category:2010 maps (showing and created)
... ... – Category:2010s maps (showing and created)
... ... – Category:Maps by year (showing and created)

--- --- --- --- ---

I think I agree, but I'm not 100% sure I understand your inverted category trees (no blame - it's hard to illustrate multiple parents in a list). You're mostly suggesting an intermediate level between Category:2010s and Category:Maps showing the 2010s/Category:Maps created in the 2010s called Category:2010s maps? Whereas now instead of Category:2010s maps serves in places of Category:Maps created in the 2010s ? If so, that's fine by me. - Themightyquill (talk) 22:46, 22 November 2017 (UTC)[reply]

Hello,

Following the logic of separating maps created in and maps showing a given year, a perfectly valid reasoning, the only logic categorization scheme is imho the following:

Category:21st century
* Category:2010s
... * Category:2011
... ... * Category:2011 maps
... ... ... - Category:Maps created in 2011
... ... ... - Category:Maps showing 2011
... ... * Category:2011 works
... ... ... - Category:Maps created in 2011
... * Category:2010s maps
... ... * Category:2011 maps
... ... ... - same as above
... ... * Category:Maps created the 2010s
... ... ... - Category:Maps created in 2011
... ... * Category:Maps showing the 2010s
... ... ... - Category:Maps showing 2011
... * Category:2010s works
... ... * Category:2011 works
... ... ... - Category:Maps created in 2011
... ... * Category:Maps created the 2010s
... ... ... - Category:Maps created in 2011
* Category:21st-century maps
... * Category:2010s maps
... ... ... same as above
... * Category:Maps made in the 21st century
... ... * Category:Maps created the 2010s
... ... ... - Category:Maps created in 2011
... * Category:Maps showing 21st-century history
... ... * Category:Maps showing the 2010s
... ... ... - Category:Maps showing 2011
* Category:21st-century works
... * Category:2010s works
... ... same as above
... * Category:Maps made in the 21st century
... ... same as above

and in parallel, the existing structure without any change:

Category:Maps by time
*Category:Maps by century made
... * Category:Maps made in the 21st century
... ... same as above
* Category:Maps by century shown
... * Category:Maps showing 21st-century history
... ... same as above

Therefore, the following categorisation templates should probably be modified (proposed changes in bold):

{{MapsYear}}, placed in Category:2011 maps, to automatically include:
- Category:2011
- Category:2010s maps (already there)
{{MapsYearShown}}, placed in Category:Maps showing 2011, to automatically include (already there):
- Category:2011 maps
- Category:Maps showing the 2010s
{{MapsYearCreated}}, placed in Category:Maps created in 2011, to automatically include:
- Category:2011 maps (already there)
- Category:2011 works (already there)
- Category:Maps created in the 2010s
{{MapsDecadeShown}}, placed in Category:Maps showing the 2010s, to automatically include:
- Category:2010s maps (instead of Category:2010s)
- Category:Maps showing 21st-century history
{{MapsDecade}}, placed in Category:2010s maps, to automatically include:
- Category:2010s
- Eventually, Category:21st-century maps which may be created.
- Note: these may be the most tricky, as this templates currently considers these categories as Maps created in... but the content seems to be more in line with Maps showing.... Content of the decades categories may be moved, preferably after having been checked.
If we create Category:Maps created in the 2010s etc. we may create a new {{MapsDecadeCreated}} with automatic inclusion in:

What do you think? Place Clichy 12:11, 28 June 2018 (UTC)[reply]

Template talk:MapsYear

Automatic Categorisation under "Category:Maps showing the DECADEs"

Navigation menu

Search