Commons talk:Deletion requests/Files in Category:Bronze statues in Agrigento

From Wikimedia Commons, the free media repository
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Igor Mitoraj, the sculptor and presumed copyright holder, installed this sculpture in a public space where it must be considered public art. The photo I took draws favorable attention to the Mitoraj's artwork and the artist himself in the context of the public installation. The photo's only purpose is to honor and glorify the artist and the artwork --also in a non-profit public space-- to enlarge and not not to diminish the intended public impact of the work of the artist. All credit goes to the sculptor, Igor Mitoraj. My connection in this regard is that of a fan and promoter of his art, from which I derive no tangible benefit, except perhaps to be recognized for my aesthetic good taste for promoting his work, certainly not for any artistry on my part for which I claim credit. I believe my posting of this photo infringes in no way on Mr. Mitoraj's rights and should be considered journalistic fair use. Sincerely, Charles Reitz, Kansas City, Missouri, USA, charlesreitz@sbcglobal.net

The problem here is different. By uploading images on Commons, you give away the right to people use them anyway they want, including commercially, restricted solely by the terms of the license (usually BY and SA). But, according to Italian laws, there is no "freedom of panorama" in Italy (see Commons:FOP#Italy). So, by placing a work of art in a public space, the sculptor does not relinquish his copyrights unless he is already dead for at least 70 years. It's very frustrating and lots of countries (including US and Brazil) have different views on that, but that's the way it is in Italy... Best regards. José Luiz disc 14:27, 28 February 2015 (UTC)[reply]