Commons:Deletion requests/Series by Nyo

From Wikimedia Commons, the free media repository
Jump to navigation Jump to search
This deletion discussion is now closed. Please do not make any edits to this archive. You can read the deletion policy or ask a question at the Village pump. If the circumstances surrounding this file have changed in a notable manner, you may re-nominate this file or ask for it to be undeleted.

Please delete all these images

[edit]
List
Motivations

I'm the uploader of all these pictures, and the author of the vast majority of them. I thought (since I'm the uploader) there wouldn't have been problems with a speedy deletion, but some users state the best way is a normal request of deletion because the images are no longer mine. When I uploaded the pictures I didn't know this policy, I thought I could require the removal whenever I wanted.

I want all those pictures to be deleted because they're low-quality and unuseful (some of my drawings are horrible). Some of them are not mine, they're from Photobucket, where the autor wrote they were free. Unfortunately the account on Photobucket no longer exists, and I can't proof there was a free license. Since I don't want to have problems, please delete also this set of pictures. --Nyo (talk) 11:04, 4 August 2008 (UTC)[reply]

Usage

[edit]

These images are indeed very valuable for the Wiki community. Many images are used in various Wikipedias; a subset follows:

fr.wikipedia.org
- 1 pages [–]
Yggdrasil dans la culture populaire uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
it.wikipedia.org
- 21 pages [–]
Alex Sanders uses: Alex_Sanders_portrait_1.PNG
Amitistianesimo uses: Lady_Amythyst.PNG
Cocranesimo uses: Four_aspects_of_the_Goddess_1.PNG
Finnismo uses: Ukkousk_symbols_on_stones.PNG
Inglinismo uses: Inglinist_Church_emblem.PNG
Sciacanesimo uses: Shacan_ritual.PNG, Shacanism_logo_red.PNG
Xandrianesimo uses: Alex_Sanders_portrait_1.PNG
Ásatrú uses: Valknut_orange_2.png
User:Petra the Cat uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Template:Sciacanesimo uses: Shacanism_logo_red.PNG
Template:Ásatrú uses: Valknut_orange_2.png
Portale:Etenismo uses: God_Odin_blue.PNG
Portale:Etenismo/Immagine uses: God_Odin_blue.PNG
Portale:Neopaganesimo uses: Pagan_woman.PNG
Portale:Neopaganesimo/Pentacolo uses: Pagan_woman.PNG
Portale:Taoismo uses: Xiantian_symbol.PNG
Portale:Taoismo/Portali correlati uses: Xiantian_symbol.PNG
Portale:Taoismo - Indice uses: Xiantian_symbol.PNG
Portale:Wicca uses: Blue_Moon.PNG
Portale:Wicca/Esbat uses: Blue_Moon.PNG
Discussioni progetto:Religione/icone uses: VoodooDeitySymbol.PNG
pt.wikipedia.org
- 3 pages [–]
Alex Sanders uses: Alex_Sanders_portrait_1.PNG
Portal:Wicca uses: Alex_Sanders_portrait_1.PNG
Portal:Wicca/Biografia Selecionada uses: Alex_Sanders_portrait_1.PNG
es.wikipedia.org
- at least 100 pages [+]
Talk:Coca Guazzini uses: Blue_Moon.PNG
Talk:Daisy Marie uses: Blue_Moon.PNG
Talk:James Potter uses: Blue_Moon.PNG
Talk:La Verdadera Iglesia de Jesús uses: Blue_Moon.PNG
Talk:Nathan Gale uses: Blue_Moon.PNG
User:Discusión:Gusgus/03-07 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG
User:Durero/Junio - Agosto 2007 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG
User:Durero/Noviembre - Diciembre 2007 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG
User:Ensada/Archivo8 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG
User:Ensada/Archivo9 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG
User:Leo.nunez uses: Blue_Moon.PNG
User:Nehiki uses: Blue_Moon.PNG
User:Techarrow/Discusiones1 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG

User talk:169.139.19.218 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:189.129.8.24 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:189.134.30.206 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:189.140.9.37 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:189.141.204.152 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:189.142.230.112 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:189.144.44.222 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:189.173.78.115 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:189.175.50.186 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:190.0.22.89 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:190.1.168.33 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:190.129.80.40 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:190.16.55.145 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:190.161.22.7 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:190.161.24.60 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:190.161.91.13 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:190.161.91.41 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:190.24.117.65 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:190.31.125.50 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:190.31.61.110 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:190.37.239.36 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:190.40.49.159 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:190.41.5.136 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:190.41.81.148 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:190.42.151.145 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:190.42.25.245 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:190.44.214.62 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:190.46.37.34 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:190.50.146.28 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:190.65.186.136 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:190.82.39.8 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:190.84.0.43 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:190.84.150.223 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:194.179.83.87 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.1.22.22 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.104.131.140 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.104.142.168 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.104.29.176 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.105.162.16 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.105.168.136 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.106.35.201 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.110.133.83 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.111.67.2 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.112.126.196 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.112.18.1 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.112.73.192 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.121.10.81 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.121.200.198 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.121.22.23 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.127.97.83 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.28.73.239 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.30.134.138 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.43.203.34 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.6.212.62 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.64.207.42 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.65.189.144 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.73.14.123 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.83.124.176 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.83.172.87 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.86.3.28 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:200.92.110.226 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:201.132.203.253 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:201.139.158.28 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:201.141.47.106 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:201.166.40.146 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:201.170.72.164 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:201.212.202.168 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:201.213.162.181 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:201.214.140.228 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:201.214.157.168 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:201.220.222.140 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:201.223.171.229 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:201.223.233.84 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:201.234.229.24 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:201.239.116.205 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:201.240.120.169 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:201.240.161.69 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:201.240.210.171 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:201.241.7.198 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:201.249.227.117 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:201.250.243.207 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:201.255.9.165 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:207.248.37.251 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:213.37.162.123 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:69.79.236.192 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:71.106.97.205 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG User talk:72.252.64.239 uses: Blue_Moon.PNG

ru.wikipedia.org
- 1 pages [+]
Славяно-Арийские Веды uses: Inglinist_Church_emblem.PNG
sv.wikipedia.org
- 1 pages [+]
User:Achird/Hedendom uses: Pagan_woman.PNG
fi.wikipedia.org
- 1 pages [+]
Template:Perinnesymboli uses: Ukkousk_symbols_on_stones.PNG
tr.wikipedia.org
- 1 pages [+]
Ruhsal eşler uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
cs.wikipedia.org
- 33 pages [–]
Baldr uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Dísy uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Einherjové uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Fenrir uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Frey uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Freya uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Ginnungagap uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Kenning uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Loki uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Norny uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Poetická Edda uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Prozaická Edda uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Ragnarök uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Ratatosk uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Runy uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Severská kosmologie uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Severská mytologie uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Seznam lidí, míst a věcí ze severské mytologie uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Seznam severských bohů uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Skald uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Snorri Sturluson uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Thór uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Týr uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Valknut uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Valkýra uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Vanové uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Yggdrasil uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Álfové uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Ásové uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Ódin uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Čísla v severské mytologii uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Template:Severská mytologie uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Template talk:Severská mytologie uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
he.wikipedia.org
- 1 pages [+]

דייוויד ליין: uses: David_Eden_Lane.PNG

gl.wikipedia.org
- 4 pages [+]
Stephen McNallen uses: Valknut_orange_2.png
Sveinbjörn Beinteinsson uses: Valknut_orange_2.png
Ásatrú uses: Valknut_orange_2.png
Template:Ásatrú uses: Valknut_orange_2.png
en.wikiquote.org
- 69 pages [–]
Albert Camus uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Albert Hofmann uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Aldous Huxley uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Aleister Crowley uses: StylizedPentacleSeasons.PNG, Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
American Gods uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Anaïs Nin uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Baruch Spinoza uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Bono uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Bruce Lee uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Buckminster Fuller uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Cyrano de Bergerac uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Dune uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Eden Ahbez uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Edie Brickell uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Edwin Markham uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Felix Adler uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Francis Bacon uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Friedrich Nietzsche uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Fyodor Dostoevsky uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
G. K. Chesterton uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Georg Christoph Lichtenberg uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Giordano Bruno uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Henry Kuttner uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Jack Kerouac uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Jalal al-Din Muhammad Rumi uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG, Blue_Moon.PNG
John Carder Bush uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Joyce Kilmer uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Julian Huxley uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Karl Mannheim uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Kate Bush uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Ken Wilber uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG, StylizedPentacleSeasons.PNG
Kenneth Rexroth uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Khalil Gibran uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Kurt Vonnegut uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Langdon Smith uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Leaves of Grass uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Loreena McKennitt uses: Blue_Moon.PNG, Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Love uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Margaret Fuller uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Mircea Eliade uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Nikola Tesla uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Nikos Kazantzakis uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Novalis uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Percy Bysshe Shelley uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Peter Kropotkin uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Philip José Farmer uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
R. A. Lafferty uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Ralph Waldo Emerson uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Richard Francis Burton uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Richard Maurice Bucke uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Robert Louis Stevenson uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Simone Weil uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Simone de Beauvoir uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Sri Aurobindo uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Starhawk uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
T. S. Eliot uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Taliesin uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Tenzin Gyatso, 14th Dalai Lama uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
The Doors of Perception uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
The Two Voices uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Vannevar Bush uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Václav Havel uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Wallace Stevens uses: Blue_Moon.PNG, Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
William Ernest Henley uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
William James uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Project:Quote of the day/August 2008 uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Project:Quote of the day/August 3, 2008 uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Project:Quote of the day/March 2008 uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
Project:Quote of the day/March 3, 2008 uses: Yggdrasil_axis_mundi_1.PNG
an.wikipedia.org
- 1 pages [+]
Template:Wicca/Direutorio uses: WiccanGodYellow.PNG
fi.wikibooks.org
- 1 pages [+]
Maailman uskonnot uses: Religious_texts_collage_small.PNG

--Foroa (talk) 14:04, 4 August 2008 (UTC)[reply]

Discussion

[edit]
  1.  Keep. As mentioned above many are used, many other are useful and some in the list wasn't even made by you and some wasn't even uploaded by you. I don't think such a blanket request is unsuitable. It would be better to take it in more manageable chunks or on a case by case basis. // Liftarn (talk)
  2.  Delete Only a few pictures among the 300+ listed are used. You can keep those used an delete all the others. --Nyo (talk) 15:02, 4 August 2008 (UTC)[reply]
If they are within scope, not copyvios and not dupes or superseded then they should be kept. // Liftarn (talk) 15:32, 4 August 2008 (UTC)[reply]
Some are not within scope, others (those from Photobucket) can be considered copyvios because the account is now down (and I suspect the photos of people are actual copyvios). --Nyo (talk) 15:37, 4 August 2008 (UTC)[reply]
  1.  Delete Delete the most. Maybe keep only this ones which are used and aren't copyvios.--Avron (talk) 16:49, 4 August 2008 (UTC)[reply]
  •  Keep Proposed deletion is far too broad, and includes many images in use in multiple Wikimedia projects that I see no valid reason for deletion. (Some individual images or subsets within this group may or may not qualify for deletion, but this broad set as a whole certainly does not. I would suggest closure as keep; individual images or subsets may be relisted seperately as appropriate.) -- Infrogmation (talk) 22:12, 4 August 2008 (UTC)[reply]
  •  Delete photobucket images  Keep the rest (for now). The photobucket ones absolutely have to go, because the license on photobucket is not free enough (it terminates once the pictures are removed from the site). As for the rest, there are too many to consider at once. Nominate them in smaller chunks. 206.170.102.210 22:23, 4 August 2008 (UTC)[reply]
  •  Delete all, many of them are obviously copyvios. --87.9.84.58 15:41, 6 August 2008 (UTC)[reply]
  •  Keep all, for now at least. Nyo asked me to view this discussion and delete these images but I can't feel comfortable doing. This request is far too broad. I've had a quick look through the comments here and a random pick of the images and it seems there is quite a variety of circumstances here. Some are used, some are not used but within project scope, some are from Photobucket with no evidence of the licensing status, and some appear to be from Photobucket with OTRS tickets although I've not reviewed these. There may well be some copyright violations within this bunch and I'll quite happily see those go but I think deleting all of the above images will go beyond addressing this issue. I'd therefore strongly suggest that these are kept for now and would encourage the nominator to create a new deletion request for smaller batches with similar issues. Adambro (talk) 19:53, 9 August 2008 (UTC)[reply]
  •  Delete Delete. --87.8.82.153 07:55, 14 August 2008 (UTC)[reply]
    Why? The administrator closing this discussion will consider the arguments made in relation to the project's policies, simple votes have only limited merit. I note that this vote is this user's only contribution. Adambro (talk) 17:15, 14 August 2008 (UTC)[reply]
  •  Keep until resubmitted in smaller bites... per the reasons above and my comment below. // FrankB 22:37, 16 August 2008 (UTC)[reply]
    • Comment I suggest the user resubmit in smaller groups. Someone has already done a lot of digging indicating which images have been used, so submit listings in smaller groups of thirty or so all those you'd rather change the licensing for is within reason. Aside from that, once one releases something, there really shouldn't be any going back. Technically, you've entered a binding contract, I would guess. As an institution, I would prefer to honor your wishes provided there is no opposition... but obviously when something is used, there is some and the foregoing has a lot of others. // FrankB 22:37, 16 August 2008 (UTC)[reply]
  • Many of those look very shaky on copyright grounds. Image:Priestess Seshen 1.PNG says "The upload of this picture is permitted by the Lycian Sanctuary" but if you follow the link you get "All material in this web site is copyrighted either by the author or the Lycian Sanctuary and may not be used, in any manner, without permission of the copyright holder." It's not used anyway, by all means delete it.
  • Even where there are OTRS submissions I'm not necessarily convinced. Image:Spider Goddess 1.PNG is an artwork by Susan Boulet (1941-1997) and not the "Erkadio" claimed on the image description page. We should delete all the Erkadio images, there are so many different styles of images purportedly by Erkadio that it's clear that they can't all be by the same author. Frankly, I'd be inclined to just go with the uploader's request and  Delete all the images - I doubt any licensing information here can be trusted. Haukurth (talk) 22:06, 3 September 2008 (UTC)[reply]
  • I went ahead and deleted all the Paganeen images for starters. Image:God Odin gray.PNG is actually a 1984 work by Alan Lee. The other artworks were in different styles and very unlikely to be by the same person. None of the photographs had metadata. The Photobucket profile has vanished and the only witness, Nyo, wants the images deleted. I think the level of proof that these were free images was far below what we accept. Haukurth (talk) 19:15, 4 November 2008 (UTC)[reply]


Deleted. The vast majority of these images have been deleted already. I am deleting the rest based on the arguments by Haukurth. MichaelMaggs (talk) 18:01, 10 February 2009 (UTC)[reply]