User talk:86.242.244.222

From Wikimedia Commons, the free media repository
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Hello User:86.242.244.222 : I notice that you have unilaterally decided to delete various coats of arms I have uploaded on to Wiki Commons, citing that they are copyright of European Heraldry! These COAs cannot be copyrighted by European Heraldry or anyone other than the bearer of such arms, who in all cases died so long ago that they were never subject to any copyright laws. In any event, the only legal body who has any control over such coats of arms is the College of Arms, and even this august institution is not empowered to issue legal sanction. Its role is, however, to advise on the appropriate use of heraldic images, and can recommend legal proceedings (but not authorise legal sanction) if COAs are inappropriately used, eg. relating to the wrong person. Any legal action could only be brought before the Court of Chivalry, but this is not the case here, because :

a) they are appropriately displayed; b) the bearers of these arms are no longer alive.

Please bear this mind & reverse your unjustified deletion of these heraldic images. Many thanks. L'honorable (talk) 22:25, 4 November 2016 (UTC)[reply]