User:Alexis Jazz/De-adminship analysis
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Here is an overview of all successful de-adminship requests (table may contain some errors, provided as-is and WIP):
| Link | Year | Initiator | Reason | Formality | Removal consensus | Resigned early | Outcome |
| Commons:Requests and votes/Joymaster (de-adminship) | 2007 | Marcus Cyron | seems like an admin that was uploading copyvios | 
|
33/6 (85%) | ||
| Commons:Requests and votes/Stahlkocher (de-adminship) | 2008 | Polarlys | admin went on a (revenge?) mass deletion spree |
|
|
26/0 (100%) | |
| Commons:Requests and votes/Gryffindor (de-adminship) | 2008 | Herrick | haven't read the whole thing, but the request could probably have been aborted because various requirements were not met. | 
|
45/23 (66%) (1 own vote) | ||
| Commons:Administrators/Requests/Florent Abel (de-adminship) | 2011 | Jcb | vote would ultimately probably have been a formality but I'm not convinced there was "consensus for removal" here either. | 
|
|
|
3/0 (100%) |
| Commons:Administrators/Requests/Abigor (de-adminship) | 2011 | Jcb | could have been aborted, issues don't appear to have "been discussed with the admin in a civil way" and community support is also not fully clear. Jcb opening the request with a sentence that was clearly taken out of context, to be honest, more or less invalidated the request anyway. If there was sufficient proof for the allegations (I'd rather not dive into the case), the request would have been a formality. |
|
12/2 (86%) | ||
| Commons:Administrators/Requests/Jcb (de-adminship 2) | 2011 | Saibo | discuss with admin in a civil way..hmm |
|
|
29/14 (69%) | |
| Commons:Administrators/Requests/High Contrast (de-adminship) | 2014 | Odder | socking admin |
|
33/1 (97%) | ||
| Commons:Administrators/Requests/JurgenNL (de-adminship) | 2014 | Jcb | WMF wanted them desysopped |
|
|
47/5 (90%) (1 moral keep) | |
| Commons:Administrators/Requests/Russavia (de-adminship 2) | 2015 | 99of9 | globally banned by WMF |
|
|
6/1 (86%) | |
| Commons:Administrators/Requests/INeverCry (de-adminship) | 2015 | Odder | "Considering INeverCry's apparent retirement, I'd think this request would be a formality" |
|
|
|
23/6 (79%) |
| Commons:Administrators/Requests/Axpde (de-adminship) | 2016 | A.Savin | consensus, with 6 admins and 1 user supporting and only Axpde opposing it was pretty much a formality. The outcome was 20 remove and 8 keep, but one keep was Axpde and 3 more keep votes appear to come from meatpuppets. But when compared to the others, it's a relatively good request. |
|
20/8 (71%) (20/4) | ||
| Commons:Bureaucrats/Requests/Kanonkas (de-bureaucrat) | 2016 | Krd | Nearly inactive admin gaming the system, request was a formality. |
|
25/0 (100%) | ||
| Commons:Administrators/Requests/H-stt (desysop) | 2017 | Jcb | wheelwarring admin so it would be expected to be a formality, and if H-stt would have made a statement to say it won't happen again the desysop would probably have failed. Quite good request. | 13/4 (76%) | |||
| Commons:Administrators/Requests/Daphne Lantier (desysop) | 2017 | A.F. Borchert | INC sock |
|
68/0 (100%) | ||
| Commons:Administrators/Requests/Fanghong (de-sysop) | 2018 | Jon Kolbert | wheelwarring admin who obtained adminship in 2005 when that much easier. Another formality. |
|
|
25/0 (100%) |
- Herrick was the only initiator who was not an administrator.
- 27% (4/15) of all de-adminship requests were started by Jcb.
- 13% (2/15) al all de-adminship requests were started by Odder.
Desysopped without de-adminship request
[edit]- Administrator User:PumpkinSky has engaged in sockpuppetry (2018, PumpkinSky, HalfGig)
Unsuccessful requests for de-adminship
[edit]Commons:Administrators/Archive/Unsuccessful requests for de-adminship
2009
[edit]2010
[edit]2011
[edit]2012
[edit]- Jameslwoodward - "some consensus for removal" missing
2013
[edit]- Russavia - "some consensus for removal" missing
- Bidgee - according to Elcobbola, "some consensus for removal" missing
2014
[edit]- Denniss - "some consensus for removal" missing
2016
[edit]- HJ Mitchell - appears valid
- Jcb - according to Ellin Beltz (bureaucrat) and several others, "some consensus for removal" missing
Nothing for 2017-2018.