Commons:Deletion requests/Files in Category:CowParade in Edinburgh

This deletion discussion is now closed. Please do not make any edits to this archive. You can read the deletion policy or ask a question at the Village pump. If the circumstances surrounding this file have changed in a notable manner, you may re-nominate this file or ask for it to be undeleted.

Files in Category:CowParade in Edinburgh

Depiction of copyrighted sculpture. Freedom of panorama doesn't apply to temporary exhibitions.

• File:A Parade of Cows - geograph.org.uk - 182205.jpg
• File:Alien Cow - geograph.org.uk - 173151.jpg
• File:An Udder Unwanted Animal - geograph.org.uk - 182608.jpg
• File:Belly Dancing Betty - geograph.org.uk - 182602.jpg
• File:Coo-ween of Hearts, Queens Hall, South Bridge - geograph.org.uk - 192394.jpg
• File:Cosmic Cow - geograph.org.uk - 182195.jpg
• File:Cow of the Castle - geograph.org.uk - 182605.jpg
• File:Cow parade participant - geograph.org.uk - 171515.jpg
• File:Cow-nections - geograph.org.uk - 182197.jpg
• File:Cow-nections - geograph.org.uk - 196129.jpg
• File:Cow-ordinate - geograph.org.uk - 182598.jpg
• File:Cows outside the National Gallery - geograph.org.uk - 232088.jpg
• File:Cows take over - Waverley. - geograph.org.uk - 232083.jpg
• File:Edinburgh Cattle - geograph.org.uk - 168563.jpg
• File:Edinburgh cow statue, 23 May 2006 (2).jpg
• File:Edinburgh cow statue, 23 May 2006.jpg
• File:Evelyn Moos - geograph.org.uk - 196143.jpg
• File:Foot of the Mound. - geograph.org.uk - 172035.jpg
• File:Grassmarket Coo - geograph.org.uk - 174029.jpg
• File:Hole in the road, Cowgate - geograph.org.uk - 233207.jpg
• File:Jack - geograph.org.uk - 196145.jpg
• File:Jones Lang LaFriesian - geograph.org.uk - 182214.jpg
• File:Metamoorphosis - geograph.org.uk - 182208.jpg
• File:Moo-rrison Cowstruction - geograph.org.uk - 182589.jpg
• File:Och Aye The Moo^ - geograph.org.uk - 196118.jpg
• File:Optimisticow - geograph.org.uk - 182606.jpg
• File:Over the Moo-n - geograph.org.uk - 196155.jpg
• File:Over the Rainbow - geograph.org.uk - 182190.jpg
• File:Phar-mooceutical - geograph.org.uk - 182596.jpg
• File:Rainforest Cow - geograph.org.uk - 182211.jpg
• File:Robocow - geograph.org.uk - 196109.jpg
• File:Scottish Parliament Building - geograph.org.uk - 196165.jpg
• File:The Cow's Pyjamas - geograph.org.uk - 173152.jpg
• File:Urbantrude - geograph.org.uk - 196110.jpg
• File:Watt a Clever Cow - geograph.org.uk - 182201.jpg
• File:Watt Cow - geograph.org.uk - 173460.jpg
• File:Interaction - geograph.org.uk - 172038.jpg
• File:The Three Grazers - geograph.org.uk - 172036.jpg

ghouston (talk) 00:56, 18 November 2012 (UTC)

• Query. I was notified of this discussion by the nominator, being the uploader of two of them (I hadn't realised they were temporary and thus fall foul of FOP), but my only interest was infact due to what was in the background. Specifically I cropped this and this, two images of a bus. Obviously the donor images cannot be kept on Commons, but I am wondering whether the crops can be re-uploaded at their cropped size, as they do show a type/livery combination that is not that easy to find on Commons compatible licenses, due to the massive recentism issues of digital photography etc. Is the CC licence used by the original Flickr photographer invalid for all types of re-use, even if it doesn't include the copyrightable portions (ie the cows)? Ultra7 (talk) 16:13, 18 November 2012 (UTC)

I actually have no idea. If the photo had been cropped in the first place before it was published on Flickr, I'm sure it would be fine. The image that you'd derive from it by cropping it afterwards would not be a derived work of the original sculpture, but it would still be a derived work of a photo of dubious legal status. ghouston (talk) 08:36, 19 November 2012 (UTC)

---

Deleted: INeverCry 00:22, 25 November 2012 (UTC)